Page 1 of 2

SANCTION

Posted: Sun Jan 07, 2007 10:54 pm
by Dr. Goodword
• sanction •

Pronunciation: sængk-shên • Hear it!

Part of Speech: Verb & Noun

Meaning: 1. [Verb] To permit, encourage, officially approve. 2. [Verb] To penalize, to forbid or discourage by exacting penalties.

Notes: Richard Lederer has called words that themselves have two contradictory meanings "contronyms", as good a name as we need. Today's contronym, when used as a noun, distinguishes its contradictory meanings by the use of discrete prepositions. A sanction to usually indicates permission while a sanction against indicates penalization. That distinction does not carry over to the verb: "The principal sanctioned short skirts," could mean that she approved them or that she forbade them.

In Play: Using a contronym requires the listener's knowing which of its meanings applies: "Iran was sanctioned for producing weapons of mass destruction by the UN long ago." We must deduce from the negative connotations of 'weapons of mass destruction' that here the verb means "penalize". "I hope using the BMW to pull the stump out of the back yard was sanctioned by Mom or Dad," however, sounds more like approval.

Word History: Today's Good Word comes from Latin sanctio(n) "consecration, confirmation" from sancire "to make holy". The past participle of this verb is sanctus, which French inherited and converted to saint. The Proto-Indo-European root, *sa[n]k- "holy, sacred", contains a Fickle N which comes and goes as it pleases historically. In sancire it is present but in sacer "holy", which was borrowed as English sacred, it is not. An interesting relative of all these words is sacrosanct, which contains this root both ways: with and without the N. (We were delighted to sanction the use of this word, sent to us by Thel Casper, in our Good Word series.)

Posted: Mon Jan 08, 2007 1:52 pm
by Perry
I'm Perry Dror, and I sanctioned this message. 8)

Posted: Mon Jan 08, 2007 11:56 pm
by skinem
No, Perry, I disagree. I sanction this message! :lol:

"Contranyms"

Posted: Tue Jan 09, 2007 6:44 am
by Don
"Sanction" and "sanction" are, we're told, contranyms -- i.e., one word with two opposite meanings. Fine. Interesting. Makes sense. But other words, we're told, are homonyms -- two differing words, each with its own meaning, which sound the same. My question is: how do we decide whether we've got a case of contranyms or homonyms? That is: why wouldn't "sanction" and "sanction" be homonyms? Is there some rule, or is this just a matter of arbitrary convention?

Don

Posted: Tue Jan 09, 2007 10:07 am
by Perry
HOMONYM: One of two or more words having the same sound and often the same spelling but different meanings. Examples: quail (cower), and quail (bird) fair (appearance), fair (county fair), and fair (reasonable).

HOMOPHONE: One of two or more words pronounced the same but different in meaning, origin, and sometimes spelling. Examples: cite, sight, and site; sea and see; your and you're; bow and bough.

HOMOGRAPH: One of two or more words spelled alike but different in origin, meaning, and sometimes pronunciation. Examples: bow of a ship, a bow and arrow, and a bow (deference/manners).

HETERONYM: One of two or more words that are spelled the same but that differ in pronunciation and meaning. Examples: bass (voice) and bass (fish); polish (shine) and Polish (from Poland); tear (rip) and tear (from eye).
I would say that a contranym is a sub-class of homonyms, singled out for having opposite, rather than merely different, meanings.

Posted: Tue Jan 09, 2007 11:40 am
by Bailey
Thank you[ and Welcome to you Don] for the information, and to you too Perry for the elaboration.

mark being-polite? Bailey

CONTRANYM | HOMONYM

Posted: Wed Jan 10, 2007 12:36 am
by Dr. Goodword
There is usually historical evidence that homonymous pairs are discrete words: fair and fair are pronounced the same as a result of historical coincidence.

A contranym is a single word with two meanings that contradict each other and the historical evidence indicates some quirk in usuage that led to their state.

Contranyms

Posted: Wed Jan 10, 2007 8:01 am
by Don
Thanks.

Just to be clear, am I right that Dr. G disagrees with Perry? Perry says that contranyms are "a sub-class of homonyms" -- i.e., that they are two words, each with its own (opposite) meaning, which sound the same. Dr. G says that contranyms are one word with two (opposite) meanings, adding that historical evidence as to how our words developed ususally can indicate to us whether we've got a case of homonym or contranym. I would be inclined to go with Dr. G's response, agreeing with him (so far as my poor powers allow) that there is historical evidence in many cases.

Don

Posted: Wed Jan 10, 2007 10:17 am
by Perry
My assertion was contextual, whereas Dr. Goodword (aka Dr. Richard Beard), actually possesses facts and specific etymological knowledge regarding this. I will just take it as a complement that you wondered (if only for a moment) which of us to believe.

IOW, what he said! :?

Posted: Wed Jan 10, 2007 8:18 pm
by gailr
In other words, Perry sanctions Dr. Goodword's message.

-gailr :wink:

Posted: Wed Jan 10, 2007 11:45 pm
by Stargzer
My assertion was contextual, whereas Dr. Goodword (aka Dr. Richard Beard),...
Robert, Perry, Robert!

Or Bob, as he signs himself in Email.

Posted: Thu Jan 11, 2007 12:16 am
by gailr
In other words, Stargzer sanctions Perry's message.

Posted: Thu Jan 11, 2007 9:01 am
by Perry
OOPS! :oops:

What to do when there are two Beards that I admire? One is our own Dr. Robert Beard and the other is Richard Beard, host of Celtic Winds Sundays 12:00 - 3:00 on WNCW (98.7 from Spindale, NC or http://www.wncw.org for listening from anywhere via the web).

Gail, it's wonderful the way you jumped on the two sides of sanction!

Posted: Thu Jan 11, 2007 10:30 pm
by sluggo
OOPS! :oops:

What to do when there are two Beards that I admire? One is our own Dr. Robert Beard and the other is Richard Beard, host of Celtic Winds Sundays 12:00 - 3:00 on WNCW (98.7 from Spindale, NC or http://www.wncw.org for listening from anywhere via the web).

Gail, it's wonderful the way you jumped on the two sides of sanction!
Kewl, I didn't know that!
But just for the record it's 88.7 -not to be picky or anything....

IOW I sanction Perry's sanction of Gailr's sanction of Stargzer's sanction of Perry's sanction of Dr. Rufolf Beard's sanction of sanction.

Sankew, sank yew vurra much.

PS - speaking of picky, contranym or contronym? One of you even did it both ways! Are they homanyms?

Re: CONTRANYM | HOMONYM

Posted: Thu Jan 11, 2007 10:47 pm
by sluggo
I thought homonyms were words pronounced alike but spelt differently.
When Dr. Goodword wrote:
There is usually historical evidence that homonymous pairs are discrete words: fair and fair are pronounced the same as a result of historical coincidence.
- did he mean fair and fare?