Page 2 of 2

Re: DEMAGOGUE

Posted: Tue Oct 09, 2012 11:00 am
by Audiendus
The idiom "overstep one's traces" has an ancient ancestor, "ultra crepidam," Latin for "beyond the sandal." The Latin phrase fused into the English verb "ultracrepidate" whose meaning and fascinating etymology would be good subjects to discuss if they have not been already.
"Ultracrepidarian" was featured as a Good Word here.

The equivalent English saying is "Let the cobbler [or shoemaker] stick to his last".

Re: DEMAGOGUE

Posted: Tue Oct 09, 2012 12:56 pm
by LukeJavan8
Let us know the response you evoke.

Re: DEMAGOGUE

Posted: Tue Oct 09, 2012 10:47 pm
by Dr. Goodword
Only three dictionaries carry ultracrepidate, according to alphaDictionary. Two only have one line about it, though the OED even offers derivations from the 19th century: ultracrepidarian and ultracrepidation.

Re: DEMAGOGUE

Posted: Wed Oct 10, 2012 3:21 am
by MTC
Thanks for the link to the previous discussion of "ultracrepidarian," Audiendus.

According to Wikipedia:

"The English essayist William Hazlitt most likely coined the term "Ultracrepidarian" as first used publicly in a ferocious letter to William Gifford, the editor of The Quarterly Review:

1819 HAZLITT Letter to W. Gifford Wks. 1902 I. 368 You have been well called an Ultra-Crepidarian critic. (Oxford English Dictionary 2nd ed.)
A related English proverb is "A cobbler should stick to his last" (a last being the wooden pattern used to mould the shoe)."

Quoting Wikipedia raises the issue of whether contributors to Wikipedia ultracrepidate.

Personally, I find the saying smacks of smug authoritarianism. Yes, generally it is correct that people should speak within their expertise, but sometimes those speaking outside their apparent competence are correct, and the "authorities" are wrong, take Alfred Wegener for instance. Though schooled in astronomy, in the face of scathing criticism from titans in the field of geology he correctly theorized that the present continents had moved ("drifted") and were once part of of a larger supercontinent, Pangaea. Eventually his ideas were refined into the modern theory of plate tectonics. Time would vindicate Wegener and leave the so-called experts with egg of their faces. His ultracrepidarian story is here http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/history/wegener.html
Perhaps the rejoinder to ne sutor ultra crepidam is even Homer sometimes nods.