either...or/both x and y
Posted: Mon Feb 22, 2010 5:55 am
As we have already discussed, 'both x and y' can have a combinatory or segregatory meaning.
Do you think this sentence is OK, or do you think it is unclear whether the conjoins are combinatory or mutually exclusive?
A story is the retelling of an event, both fictional and nonfictional.
Would you prefer the sentence to be written as below, to avoid any misinterpretations?
A story is the retelling of an event, either fictional or nonfictional.
It is a characteristic of reduced clauses, both adverbial and relative, to be non-finite.
This, I feel, clearly has a segregatory meaning.
What is the difference (if any) between using 'both x and y' and 'either or' in such cases?
Do you think this sentence is OK, or do you think it is unclear whether the conjoins are combinatory or mutually exclusive?
A story is the retelling of an event, both fictional and nonfictional.
Would you prefer the sentence to be written as below, to avoid any misinterpretations?
A story is the retelling of an event, either fictional or nonfictional.
It is a characteristic of reduced clauses, both adverbial and relative, to be non-finite.
This, I feel, clearly has a segregatory meaning.
What is the difference (if any) between using 'both x and y' and 'either or' in such cases?